《Taiwan’s Threat to China’s National Security: Moral Legitimacy and Voice》

發布時間 | 2025/08/12 12:49
作者 | Peter Tozzi, TIA Research Fellow
Taiwan’s Threat to China’s National Security: Moral Legitimacy and Voice


On July 4, Taiwan Inspiration Association (TIA) hosted a symposium on “China’s Threat to Taiwan’s National Security.” The symposium examined the Chinese Communist Party’s (CCP) increasing threats to Taiwan, and Taiwan’s strengths to combat the CCP. The speakers established Taiwan’s strengths as rooted in moral legitimacy and having a distinct voice.


The event featured speeches by Mr. Piero A. Tozzi, the staff director of the United States’ Congressional-Executive Commission on China (CECC), and Sir Gavin Williamson, a current member of British parliament and former Secretary of State for Defence and Education. The symposium was moderated by Ms. Orina Chang, chair professor and associate dean at National Sun Yat-sen University.


Taiwan’s Strength: Moral Legitimacy


Mr. Tozzi argued that Taiwan’s strength against the CCP lies in its moral legitimacy. Taiwan is a thriving democracy, which respects human rights and the rule of law. Taiwan’s democratic system stands in stark contrast to the CCP’s totalitarianism. This very fact penetrates the Party’s odious and false claims that its rule by law governance is legitimate and that the Chinese people are ill-suited for freedom. According to Tozzi, Taiwan’s moral narrative can allow the nation to “go on the offense” by breaking through the “Great Firewall” at a time of great political and social vulnerability for the CCP. If the Great Firewall is penetrated, Taiwan can speak directly to the Chinese people.


Rhetoric is therefore powerful. At times, it can accomplish far more than tanks and missiles ever could. Tozzi noted how during the Cold War, leaders like President Ronald Reagan and Pope Saint John Paul II spoke with fortitude and moral clarity against the Soviet Union (USSR). President Reagan framed the USSR as an “evil empire,” and called upon “Mr. Gorbachev [to] tear down this wall.” The Pope rallied the Polish against the USSR, making Poland the first “crack” in the Soviet bloc.


President Lai Ching-te seems to be continuing the legacy of Reagan and John Paul II—albeit in his own style. President Lai’s “10 Talks on the Country” introduce a variety of topics ranging from nationhood to democracy and rule of law. Tozzi recalled an interaction he had with President Lai on his ten talks. While President Lai stated that these speeches are primarily designed to educate the Taiwanese people, it can be inferred that they are also tailored for the Chinese people. Tozzi added that President Lai’s message is getting across the Strait, as demonstrated by frantic articles published by the CCP’s Global Times and China Daily.


Finding Taiwan’s Voice: Peace Through Strength, Not Peace Through Appeasement


Sir Gavin emphasized that Taiwan’s strength lies in finding its own voice—one that is distinct from its neighbor across the Strait. Taiwan should also begin by demanding more from its allies and partners. While Taiwan seeks a “relationship of peace and friendship” with other nations, China seeks to “squeeze out” the United States and European nations from Asia and assert dominance over its neighbors. Sir Gavin argued that Taiwan must emphasize this reality to persuade nations to make a choice between Taiwan and China, and to reflect on their values and priorities.


Reflecting on his experience as Secretary of State for Defence, Sir Gavin witnessed firsthand the apathy of many within his own country and across Europe toward resisting CCP aggression. He noticed how some would “moderat[e] their actions in order to appease” China. Sir Gavin recalled that he was met with “universal resistance” when he ordered the Royal Navy to sail through the Taiwan Strait. The underlying fear among Sir Gavin’s peers was fear of CCP retribution. However, Beijing’s response was nothing more a mere dog’s bark.


As Sir Gavin noted, appeasement “will not change a tyrant”—only strength will. His decision to conduct a freedom of navigation exercise called out Beijing’s bluff by projecting strength. The CCP views appeasement as weakness, and weakness is often exploited. The absence of resolve presents an opportunity for Beijing’s rulers to “take more.” Thus, peace is achieved through strength, not appeasement, a lesson that many countries seem to have forgotten.


Concluding Thoughts: Conveying Moral Clarity


Like a “North Star” which stands in its place as other stars surround it and “pay homage,” Taiwan’s strength lies in its moral legitimacy and its voice. Taiwan’s democracy, respect for human dignity, and rule of law demonstrate the fruits of a free and open society—especially for the Chinese people. Although Taiwan cannot militarily match the CCP one-for-one, its moral clarity can expose the CCP’s totalitarianism, suppression of human rights, and rule by law. By shattering the Great Firewall, Taiwan can combat the CCP’s falsities with a unified voice rooted in the truth.


If you missed the symposium, a recording of it can be found on TIA’s Facebook page.



Peter Tozzi, TIA Research Fellow

最新文章

其他活動心得分享